The Game
The Game lgbt love stories

aknier I occasionally remember to write things
Autoplay OFF   •   3 years ago
I almost went sad with the "liar" prompt but it turned out sweet instead. Hope you enjoy! **Some mature language**

The Game

My best friend Sam and I had a game we always played

We'd look up facts, create stories, whatever we could do

Then, we'd tell them to each other

If you thought the other person's story was fake, you'd shout "Liar!"

If you were right, you got a point

If you were wrong, they got a point

We invented the game in 3rd grade, and now were still playing our senior year

The game was the reason I knew that banging your head against a wall burns 150 calories an hour,

that heart attacks are more likely to happen on a Monday,

and that Sam had a crush on our friend Rachel

It came out on a Saturday night sleepover

We were playing halfheartedly while I kicked his ass at Mario Kart

"A baby octopus is the size of a grape when it's born." I said

"Truth." He said

"Wrong!" I laughed

"Osaka is the biggest city in Japan." He answered

"Liar!" I shouted while chucking a red shell at him

He growled, and I knew I was right

"You can't snore and dream at the same time" I said

"Liar!" He called back, and I laughed. "Wrong!"

"Seriously? How are you winning at both games?" He yelled

"I dunno, guess I'm just more awesome than you in every way." I answered, crossing the finish line

"I like Rachel" He snapped at me

It felt like a punch in the throat

I just sat there, dazed, unable to process what he'd just said

"Dude, you gonna call it or not?" He asked me

I whispered back "Liar", fervently hoping I was right and this was some kind of stupid joke

He shot me a grin a wink. "Gotcha. Now we're tied."

He didn't know.

He couldn't possibly know what he'd done, because I was too much of a chicken to tell him.

I couldn't tell him that his smile made me weak at the knees

That his laugh was like music to me

That I dreamed about holding him, kissing him, telling him I loved him

That him liking Rachel was like my nightmare.

Rachel is the prettiest one of our friends

I'm gay, and even I can see it

She's smart, and funny, and unlike me, she has boobs

Of course Sam would like her

It made sense

I left his house early that night

Claiming I felt sick

Really, heartbroken would be a better description

But I couldn't tell him that

As soon as I got home, I texted my friend Autumn

She was the only one who I'd come out to, and the only one who I could talk about Sam to

She answered right away

We stayed up half the night talking about Sam, and her girlfriend Paige

She tried to convince me to tell him how I felt, but I couldn't bring myself to do it

At last, I decided I'd just try to support him with Rachel

Autumn wasn't happy about it, but she promised to support me

For the next two weeks, I was miserable

Everywhere I went, I saw Rachel

And every time I was with Sam, my throat closed up

But I just kept quiet

Then, the next weekend, Sam was at my place

We were swimming in my pool, dunking each other and laughing when the other one spluttered

Out of the blue, he said to me

"Dude, I gotta ask you something."

Nervous and panicky, I answered, "what's up?"

"That's my question." He responded. "What's up with you? You're acting so weird lately, ever since I told you about Rachel."

"Weird? What do you mean?" I tried to cover, failing miserably at seeming casual

"Ok. Game. Tell me, and I'll guess." He said

"Nothing's wrong."


I sighed, nodding.

"You're mad I like Rachel?" He guessed

I nodded

"It's not a big deal." I said



"You like Rachel?" He asked

I snorted, shaking my head vigorously

"Then what is it?" He almost shouted

I almost made something up, or changed the subject, or anything else

But instead, I did something that shocked me almost as much as it shocked him

I told him the truth

"I like you, Sam."

"Liar." He whispered.

I shook my head.

"God, Bryce, quit playing. Liar. Liar. You're lying."

Tears starting streaming down my cheaks

He just stared at me as I shook my head no again and again

"You're lying." He whispered

"No." I whispered back

He jumped out of the pool, grabbed his towel, and ran away

I cried.

The next weekend, Autumn came over to cheer me up

But no matter how many cookies she baked me, I couldn't forget that Sam hadn't contacted me in over a week

No phone calls, no texts, not even a nod in the school hallway


Finally, Autumn had enough of my moping

She shoved me into my bedroom and ordered me to change my clothes

I did, mostly because I'm afraid of her when she's bossy

Half an hour later, we were pulling up at a huge house party

"C'mon Bryce. You're gonna drink, dance, have fun, and forget about Sam. That's an order." Autumn yelled in my ear

Not seeing another option, I nodded and followed her into the house

An hour later, I was feeling much better

I'd chugged a couple drinks and was dancing with Autumn when she suddenly whipped around

Her girlfriend Paige had just walked in, dressed to kill and on a mission

Autumn turned back to me, looking so torn that my heart broke for her

"Go! Make out with your girl, I'll be fine." I yelled in her ear

She shot me a grateful smile and ran off

Now alone, I decided I needed to drink more if I wanted to stay in a good mood

So I did.

I drank a lot, actually.

So much that the room started spinning, and my head got foggy, and all of a sudden, I was collapsing into somebody's arms.

I woke up the next morning with a killer headache, not knowing where I was

I looked around and recognized the four poster bed, the cluttered desk, and the totally uncool lava lamp instantly

I was in a room that was almost a second home to me

Sam's room

I looked around, but didn't see Sam himself anywhere

So, hoping to salvage what was left of my dignity, I tottered over to his bathroom and climbed in the shower

When I left the bathroom, now clean but still wearing my clothes from last night, Sam was sitting on his bed

I cleared my throat nervously, and he whipped around

"Hey." I whispered

"Hey." He said back

We both stood there awkwardly for a few minutes, not sure how to act

"I brought you some painkillers." He said. "I bet your head's killing you."

"It is." I whispered. "Thanks."

I took the pills from his outstretched hand, trying to touch his skin as little as possible

"Dude, I'm not gonna bite you." He said

I swallowed hard and nodded, looking into his eyes for the first time

I was surprised at what I saw

He didn't seem disgusted, or angry

Just nervous, unsure

A lot like how I was feeling

I gave him a half smile, and he broke into a huge one

"I'm sorry I didn't text you." He said after a while

"It's okay." I answered

"No it's not. You put yourself out there and I didn't even talk to you. That was shitty of me." He said

I thought for a second, then nodded

He laughed

"Anyway, I've been wanted to talk to you but wasn't sure how to. And after last night-" He started

"What happened last night?" I asked

"You don't remember?" He said

"No. Nothing."

"We were all playing spin the bottle and well... we kissed." He said

My heart stuttered to a stop.

I kissed Sam? And didn't remember it?

My life really was hell.

"And when I was kissing you, I realized something."

I knew what he was going to say. It was awkward, or gross, or that he regretted it-

"I wanted to do it again." He whispered

"Wait, what?" I blurted

"Bryce, I realized I like you too." He said

Tears bubbled up then, and I started sobbing

"Liar!" I shouted

"You're sick, this is a terrible joke, you know that. Who put you up to this? You bastard!" I screamed, hardly able to breathe through my blubbering

"Bryce, I-" He tried to explain, but I wouldn't let him

"How could you? I know you don't feel the same, but to lie about something like this-" My words were hardly words now, they were more like sobs

"Bryce, I'm not lying, I-"

"Stop it, stop it, stop it!" I screamed

I ran to the bathroom and slammed the door behind me

After a minute, I heard Sam's quiet voice outside

"Bryce, please let me explain. Open the door, please."

I shook my head, even though he couldn't see me

The door creaked open, and I realized I'd forgotten to lock it

"Bryce, I-"

"I won't let you talk. You'll just make it worse."

"Fine. I won't talk then." He yelled, grabbing my arm

I flinched, closing my eyes

But he didn't hit me, or shove me, or whatever else I thought he was going to do

Instead, he cupped my jaw in his hand, and pulled me close

Before pressing his lips to mine

I gasped against his touch, and he took the opportunity to deepen the kiss, sliding his tongue into my mouth and making me see stars

We clung to each other, pressed together, for what felt like seconds and days all at the same time

When we finally parted, my eyes fluttered open

And what I saw was my best friend, my biggest crush, and my first kiss staring back at me

And huge smile on his face

"I like you, Bryce." He whispered

"Truth?" I whispered back

And when he nodded, the whole world seemed right again


My husband Sam and I had a game we always played

The game was how I learned catfish are the only animals that naturally have an odd number of whiskers,

that sea otters hold hands when they sleep,

and that Sam was proposing-

All true

Stories We Think You'll Love 💕

Get The App

App Store